h1

Mature and Dark Subjects in a Children’s Book?

November 17, 2009

I have heard the question why there are such dark/harmful subjects in Alice.

There is one article that talks about the caterpillar smoking a hookah and how this sends the wrong impression on children. That is because people back in Carroll’s time did not the dangers of smoking and that smoking was a common pastime. Also in the eighteen hundreds, opium was thought to be a medicine.

There is also the Queens constant need for beheading people for random actions. This might be because death was a common thing in the eighteen hundreds and that there was a rise in crime. This would also explain chapter 11 with the Knave’s trial about if he stole the tarts.

Then there is the death jokes, where Alice thinks of different ways that she could be killed. This would have been common because of the increase in dangerous chemicals and materials that followed the Industrial Revolution and that parents would want their children to be aware.

But there is also when she is falling down the Rabbit-hole and she says that she would tell nobody about her falling, even if she fell off the top of the house, on which she thinks that this is probably true. Alice also has a habit of talking about how great her cat(Dinah) is good at killing animals. Why would Alice continue in bring Dinah into a conversations with the creatures of Wonderland if she knew that they feared and hated cats? Dinah is Alice’s several connections to the real world in Wonderland and that killing of animals was a sport during these time before animal rights becomes a reality.

So in the time period that Carroll writes Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland and his other works would have no effect on children during his lifetime because of the life style of people in England. Put the complaints come from people who lived during the times of new knowledge and ethics. Therefore, Carroll’s book is not inappropriate for children, but was written for children of a different time.

One comment

  1. Wow! I like this post. Alex brings up a very good point here. When little children read this story, they can, at some point, maybe get the wrong impression of the story. When Alice comes across the Caterpillar with the hookah in its mouth, it is natural to assume that the character could be insane. People, in this world, who usually smoke tend to go somewhat crazy, and have absolutely no idea where they are or what they are doing. Carroll doesn’t make it this way, however. I mean sure, the Caterpillar is a little strange, but in a way, he helps Alice through her struggles.

    Alex also brings up a good point about the Queen with her constant needs for execution. Many readers can get the wrong impression here as well. Many may think that the Queen is meaning what she actually says, and there will be a scene in the story describing an execution. But, Carroll doesn’t display this at any point of the story. She just writes and describes how the Queen says, “Off with his/her head!”, but this is probably just to get the reader’s interest and attention.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.